Improving Student Questioning
See handout
Core skills that enable us to be capable questioners.
- Identify the need or problem
- Identify, understand and use the relevant contextual vocabulary (key words and key phrases)
- Ask a range of relevant questions
- Take their questions to a range of appropriate sources
- Persist, editing questions as necessary until they acquire the needed information
Rudyard Kiplings - the Elephant Child - great poem to introduce open questions (6 of the 7 servants).
What is a good question?
- relevant
- gets you the needed information (open or closed)
- is worded well enough so it can be taken to intelligent (person) and non-intelligent (stored resource - internet, books...) sources. Questions must have all keywords and phrases.
If you are going to answer a poor question answer the asked question, not the one you think the student is trying to ask, then check with the student to see if your response answered their actual question.
Questioning Skill Taxonomy
- Created statements rather than questions (or a null response)
- Any non-relevant question (does not contain contextual key words or phrases)
- Asks yes/no/maybe questions using relevant key words and /or phrases (is, can, does, could, may ...)
- Uses the 7 servants and the key words to write relevant questions (who, what, when, where, how, why and which)
- Uses the 7 servants and the key phrases to write relevant questions (who, what, when, where, how, why and which)
- Using relevant synonyms of key words to edit key questions.
- Using multiple question words to create a probing question when interviewing an ‘expert’.
Aim is to get students out of Type 1 and Type 2 questions and across the range of 3 ~ 7.
Graphically can use the Waka or Hot Air Balloon.
Strategies to grow effective questioners.
- provide students the knowledge to support developing good questions (using the matrix)
- support self assessment of questions (using the matrix)
- create activities with real needs eg PE gear getting lost
- support and scaffold students to identify needs
- create and use a wondering wall
- model good questions (or poor ones but tell kids and use the matrix to improve the questions
- probe into questions as they are asked (but strategy 10 is better!)
- probe into questions that may not have gained the student the answer they were looking for
- celebrate good questions
- turn questions into activities, be a companion learner not an encyclopaedia